1. Startseite
  2. Journal

Ice barrel or bathtub with a chiller: which is better?

An ice barrel or your own bathtub with a chiller: space, cold, cost and hygiene, compared honestly.
  • Aurel Hampl
  • 6 Min. Lesezeit
  • Studienbasiert
Einstieg in das aufblasbare Gefäß neben dem pool.down Tower Pro

In Germany, the “Eistonne” (ice barrel) is the word for cold plunging at home. But a barrel alone doesn't make cold water. Here is the honest comparison: what an ice barrel is, what it costs, how the water stays cold and clean, and when your own bathtub with a chiller is the simpler choice.

What is an ice barrel?

An ice barrel is a round, open-top tub in which you sit upright in cold water up to your shoulders. They come inflatable with an insulated lid, as plastic barrels and as wooden tubs.

Inflatable models are easy to store; wooden tubs are heavy and stay in place. What they all share: the barrel is only the container. For the cold you need ice, very cold weather or a water chiller.

Ice barrel or bathtub with a chiller: what's the difference?

An ice barrel needs a permanent spot, usually outdoors; the bathtub is already in your bathroom. In the barrel you sit upright, in the tub you lie down; both reach your shoulders.

Ice barrel Bathtub with chiller
Space its own spot, usually garden, terrace or basement the tub you already have
Cold buying ice, winter weather or a separate chiller the chiller holds the set temperature
Water usually stays in the barrel for days, changed with a hose or pump fill fresh, drain after the bath
Position sitting upright lying or half-sitting
Winter water can freeze outdoors indoors, independent of the weather

How does the water in an ice barrel get cold?

Without a chiller, only with ice or in winter: tap water alone is usually too warm, so you add ice that you buy fresh for every bath. For a bathtub we estimate around 20⁠–⁠25 kg (44⁠–⁠55 lbs) of ice per bath; a barrel holding more water tends to need more.

With a chiller, the water stays cold. According to typical manufacturer specifications, many compact chillers around €1,000 need 6 to 12 hours to go from 15 to 3 °C, because their cooling capacity is mostly under 1 kW. The pool.down Tower Pro runs with more than 1.5 kW, the class of pro chillers from studios: you can take your first ice bath after approx. 90 minutes, in your bathtub or optionally in the inflatable tub for outdoors. What ice costs over a year is worked out in Ice bath costs: ice cubes or a chiller?

What does an ice barrel cost?

Inflatable ice barrels start at around €60 in stores, wooden tubs at about €1,100 (retail prices, November 2026). On top come the running costs for the cold: ice for every bath, or a chiller plus electricity.

With a bathtub there is no container to buy; you only pay for the chiller. With the Tower Pro, one cooling cycle costs less than 49 cents at current electricity prices.

How long and how cold in an ice barrel?

The same values apply in a barrel as in a bathtub: 12⁠–⁠15 °C (54⁠–⁠59 °F) and one to two minutes to start. After exercise, water at 11⁠–⁠15 °C was linked to the clearest effect on muscle soreness in a meta-analysis; colder was not better (Machado et al., 2016).

Experience Temperature Duration
Beginner 12⁠–⁠15 °C 1⁠–⁠2 minutes
Intermediate 8⁠–⁠12 °C 2⁠–⁠4 minutes
Experienced 3⁠–⁠8 °C 2⁠–⁠5 minutes

These are guide values from experience, not medical recommendations. More in Ice bath: which temperature and how long?

11⁠–⁠15 °C

Water temperature with the clearest effect on muscle soreness after exercise

Machado et al., 2016 (meta-analysis)

Well supported

~5

short baths until the cold shock becomes measurably weaker

Tipton et al., 2000

Well supported

11 min

of cold per week in experienced winter swimmers, spread over several baths

Søberg et al., 2021

Observation

How does the water in an ice barrel stay clean?

Change standing water without a filter regularly, at the latest when it turns cloudy, smells or a film forms at the edge. A lid keeps out leaves and dirt, and a quick shower before getting in helps too.

A bathtub is filled fresh for every bath. The Tower Pro also filters the water with a washable filter and cleans it with active oxygen.

What speaks for the ice barrel

  • Sitting upright, as in many studios
  • Outdoors, in the fresh air
  • Low-cost entry with inflatable models

What speaks for the bathtub with a chiller

  • No extra space, no hauling ice
  • Fresh water every time
  • Independent of weather and season

Is an ice barrel dangerous?

For healthy people a short, calm ice bath is manageable, but the cold shock in the first minute puts strain on the heart and circulation. Getting out of a tall barrel is also harder than out of a bathtub: keep a step ready and don't bathe alone if you are unsure.

If you have cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, heart rhythm disorders, Raynaud's syndrome, are pregnant or have other pre-existing conditions, talk to your doctor first. Don't jump in, don't submerge your head, and never bathe under the influence of alcohol. This article does not replace medical advice.

Frequently asked questions

Buying an ice barrel: what should I look for?

Enough height to reach your shoulders, an insulated lid, a drain for changing the water and a firm, level base. Decide beforehand how the water will get cold: ice, winter or a chiller.

Can I put an ice barrel on my balcony?

Only after checking the load capacity: a full barrel of 400 litres plus a person easily weighs over 450 kg (990 lbs). If in doubt, ask your landlord or a structural engineer.

Can I cold plunge without an ice barrel?

Yes, in any bathtub where you can sit in the water up to your shoulders. How to start is explained in the guide: ice bath at home, and we answer all other questions in Cold plunging: all questions and answers.

Sources

  1. Machado AF et al. (2016): Can Water Temperature and Immersion Time Influence the Effect of Cold Water Immersion on Muscle Soreness? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Sports Medicine 46, 503⁠–⁠514.
  2. Tipton MJ, Mekjavic IB, Eglin CM (2000): Permanence of the habituation of the initial responses to cold-water immersion in humans. European Journal of Applied Physiology 83, 17⁠–⁠21.
  3. Søberg S et al. (2021): Altered brown fat thermoregulation and enhanced cold-induced thermogenesis in young, healthy, winter-swimming men. Cell Reports Medicine 2(10), 100408.
  4. Retail prices for ice barrels (inflatable and wooden), retrieved November 2026.

Dein Eisbad in deiner Badewanne. Ohne Eiswürfel.

Der pool.down Tower Pro kühlt das Wasser deiner Wanne, ganz ohne Eiswürfel. Temperatur am Display oder per App einstellen.

Tower Pro entdecken

14-day right of return · Free pickup for returns (DE)